Revan vs Hero of Tython

This was an interesting idea I came up with in the chatbox...

Sabers
Force
All-out

I feel like Revan is a bit more impressive from what we've seen. A lot of people rate HOT higher because he beat Vitiate and Revan couldn't. I however do not see this as good enough to put him above Revan. Revan fought Vitiate in his true body while the Hero fought a weakened voice.

yeah im with you dmb, Revan is much more experience and well versed in the sith arts as well as the jedi arts, and while the Hero Of Tython may be power he is somewhat limited by his jedi Code while Revan is free of limitations and restraints

Truthfully I am not overly impressed by Vitiate's voice.

Lol, is the Revan fan (myself) really the only one not voting for him?
Quite frankly, the way I view it, the Hero succeeded Revan's failed mission.

I go with the Hero as well, it's funny how i've always told dmb to read th hero's respect thread yet he never does.

well if it's on SWF I certainly don't have access to it.

It's on kmc.  So honestly, im just gonna make a respect thread of respect threads so i dont keep hearing "HoT=Dooku!" or, "Darth Nox < Maul!"

Well if you think about it, Revan was still in a drugged state, yet he was still able to stand on even ground with Vitiate's true 'self', which was powered by his past rituals. While the hero defeated the 'voice' of the emperor, to be honest Vitiate is impressive, but because of his voice techniques his power was scattered and not whole. IMO.

I always considered it in the context that Vitiate's true body is a superior channel for his power than his voices.

Yes, because while he's attempting what was at the time the deadliest, most dangerous, most powerful force ritual ever recorded, he'd weaken himself by using the children and the emperor's hands -_-

His consciousness is in the children/hands, sure, but he also siphons power from them as well.

Emperordmb wrote:

I always considered it in the context that Vitiate's true body is a superior channel for his power than his voices.

It's canonically stated that voice voice harbors the power of the emperor himself....

It harbors his power but his true body is better at channeling it.

Emperordmb wrote:

It harbors his power but his true body is better at channeling it.

Really?

That's my speculation but it's not unsupported. I'll post my speculation threads soon enough. Some of them are on KMC and I'd advise you to check them out.

The Hero impresses me more even disregarding their respective performances against Vitiate, he's a certified badass with or without.

I agree.  The Hero doesn't only have his bout against Vitiate as a feat.